There are no criteria for this award, other than the person has to be a member of this website, obviously... are you retarded or something... you want to nominate Sherdog members? What's wrong with you?
Post your nominations here, and your reasons for nominating them (unless those reasons involve you having an intimate relationship, in which case, keep it to yourself).
McClaw has been on there way too long. Bump him off with his animes and chain mails and progressive views on gender identities and what not.